Now first of all as a small disclaimer I am applying both to GULC and Cornell as they are both dream schools of sort for me and I don't want to get stuck saying what if. But in the highly likely scenario that I get denied admission or can't cough up tuition I am looking to stay in state. So out which school leaves me with the best job prospects, University of Cincinnati, OSU Moritz, or Case Western? I am not looking for anything crazy or out of the midwest. Just decent job prospects within the Cleveland, Cinci, Indianapolis or Chicago markets.

Talk to a headhunter/legal recruiter in that area. They know the best and will give you a straight answer.

what abouut michigan

I agree that a headhunter in the area you want to work will tell you which schools are most marketable.